19th
Singapore Taxis - call for action!
Singapore has one of the highest ratio of taxis to area (86 cabs per sq mile!) than most countries in the world, yet it is the most difficult place on Earth to catch a cab. The system is very, very broken and here are some of the reasons why:
Taxi Booking –
As well as flagging down an available car at the roadside, or waiting at a designated taxi rank, you can also use telephone bookings, or smart phone apps available for iPhone and Android. However, be warned, this not only costs you extra, it is likely to drive you mad!!!
1) Capacity of the system(s)
The phones are often not answered! No idea why – but they just ring and ring…
The smart phone apps timeout all the time – often resulting in “no taxis are available, please try again in 10 min” messages, or worse still the app crashes completely so when you go back in, you end up accidentally booking two or three cars when you only wanted one! (The phone app crashes but the booking was logged but you have no way to tell)
This is all “normal” operating procedures…so now add a weighting/loading factor for peak times like 7am-9am, or 5pm-7pm. Then pray it isn’t raining too!
2) Finding you
This is my favourite problem with bookings as it’s absolute madness. After a while experience tells you there are three outcomes really from a successful booking:
i) The taxi comes for you and you pay your extra $ to arrive happily at your destination;
ii) The taxi can’t find you – so the driver cancels your booking and you’re left stranded. This is far more common than you’d like to think, and more worryingly is that you live in a really well known area…they just couldn’t be bothered or have picked up someone else on the road..anyway you just have to guess as you get no feedback or means of complaining.
iii) The taxi can’t find you – so the driver calls your mobile to yell at you for not being where they think you should be!?!? So you have to guide them to your location via the phone.
The ratio of these results varies but in my experience it’s 25:50:25 percent! That’s right, only 25% of the time will the taxi locate you even though the computerised system is GPS and your request for pickup is locked to specific address formats and locators.
The reason given is that construction in Singapore is constant, new buildings, new streets and addresses all the time. Which is kind of true, kind of an excuse and kind of irritating as I’m sure Robertson Quay has been here a long time! Real reason would seem to be the lack of learning – I’m not sure the level of training needed to be a taxi driver in Singapore but it wouldn’t seem on the face of it to be as exhaustive as “the knowledge”.
3) Charging you.
This is a new one to me but I’ve experienced it recently – when my taxi arrived to pick me up, the meter was already running. I asked the driver why and he, rather aggressively, told me that he started the meter when he couldn’t find my address – because “why should he look for me on his own time and money – I should pay for that”!?! So not only did I pay for the booking, he wanted me to also pay for him aimlessly driving about for 3-5 mins trying to find my condo! Needless to say I didn’t and got out of the car as he hurled abuse at me…
Shift-change – only place in the world where taxis tell you where it’s going and if, coincidentally, you happen to be wanting to be going the same way, then you can go with them.
The cars curb-crawl like some sleazy red-light area, windows down, driver leaning out touting for business. Of course they block up the curb, fill the taxi ranks as they roll by slowly, scanning the queues for victims customers, and legitimately “free” taxis can’t stop…so queues get longer and everyone gets more frustrated. Including the drivers whom seem very annoyed that you don’t want to go home with them!!
Now, the drivers will tell you there is nothing wrong with this practice, they often share cars etc and it’s logical to try and maximise income by getting a fare to pay for your journey home! But…and it’s a big but…why will they only take a fare that is going entirely & specifically the full journey to their destination??!? For example, you wanna go to Bedok but they want a fare all the way to Tampines, so you’re screwed, even though it’s on the way, they would rather driver off empty than take you. I even had a driver tell me that’s because he won’t get a customer travelling the extra way!?!?! No sense of customer service – the only customer you should care about is the one in front of you!
Why do all the shifts change at the same time! Surely these can be staggered? Seems like the whole force is changing between 3 and 4pm!
Airport run – there is a great practice that taxis get an extra $ for a pickup at the airport after 11pm…so at 11pm where are 50% of all the island’s working taxis? Yes, you guessed it, all queuing up – often double parked queues for the 2 km leading up to airport arrivals bay. Meantime, all the city areas have queues of people at taxi stands that can’t get a car! Still the drivers will tell you “it’s worth it” for that extra few dollar – even when I tried a couple of times to point out the economics of using the same elapsed time that they queued at the airport they could have had 3 or 4 short runs around the CBD and made twice as much, this draws blank looks – you see this is what they have been taught and they have always done it, so it can’t possibly be uneconomical! At some point in the past I can see this being a policy to encourage drivers to go to the airport…what we need now is balance - encouragement for drivers to go to designated ranks all over the island.
So….
So the system is very broken and there doesn’t seem to be any attempt to fix it…and now this week, the Singapore gov announced that drivers can continue working until 75 years of age. Good for families with elderly drivers that want to keep earning…not so good for customers whom were hoping for a younger set of drivers that would a) know what English signs said; b) could find addresses that were new after 1985; c) can drive in the rain; d) can work the GPS system and e) wouldn’t chase every extra $ sitting empty in a queue in favour of earning 10x that by actually picking people up. But it’s not just about age of the driver, it’s more about age of the practices and ingrained customs/practices of the trade – it needs review.
All of that said, there are a solid group of taxi drivers of varying ages that are very, very kind, thoughtful and professional. I just wish there were more of them. Maybe they should form a union and help improve the industry from within, kick out the cowboys and strive for continuous improvement. Mind you, if all passengers were equally as nice and considerate, then maybe the service would be better from cabbies. Overall though people are crap to each other the world over, but to catch a cab, Singapore is worse than anywhere else..time for a review, so come on LTA – force some changes…